When considering the playing of a melody on an instrument and its performance by voice, several rules of performance can be identified.
***
Firstly, a melody for a musical instrument and a melody for a vocalist will differ significantly.
In a melody for an instrument, large leaps (intervals greater than an octave) can be played. Moreover, higher leaps up or down won’t harm the melody either.
In a melody for vocals, the difficulty lies in the fact that it will be performed by a living person, with their own vocal capabilities and limitations. The lyrics also play a significant role in such a melody. Intervals in the middle of words can be sung awkwardly and awkwardly, and the meaning of the song can be lost as a result. Attention should be paid to the national stress in the words.
There are melodies that are equally easy to perform with both voice and instrument. These melodies are often used in songs instead of the theme or chorus motif.
***
Secondly, a melody may be written for a specific instrument and vocal timbre, so it’s important to select a suitable one. This isn’t an easy task. You might not even find a similar vocal at all.
***
Thirdly, you need to consider the melody’s register. For example, a melody in the high register of an electric guitar is not the same as its performance in the middle register, and even less so in the lower register. It’s the same with vocals: a tenor will perform melodies wonderfully in their own register, while a bass and soprano will sound good at the edges of the musical texture, but if they are swapped, only a few will be able to carry the part.
A melody for a voice is easily performed on an instrument. However, the capabilities of any musical instrument are usually emphasized by the breadth of its range. Therefore, a “narrow” melody structure will not be as effective for the instrument.
***
These are just a few details of writing and performing music.
Want to know more? Let me know in the comments.
